reason for not choosing ESF

salseros

Registered User
We are new here, and now choosing schools for my 5 year old son.

We think ESF would be good for our boy, but I would like to know your sincere opinion.

We see a lot of English natives not going to ESF, but going to other international schools.

Could you please advise why you chose other shools?
 
My oldest will be going to ESF in September. I think sometimes a reason for people not to go is another language, like German, French, etc. I also think ESF has a fairly high percentage of locals, so some schools "look" pretty Asian. To me that's fine, that's part of living in HK, but others may want to have a less Asian feel. They may think quality (of e.g. English) may be of a less higher standard. Classes are usually on the bigger side, 30 kids per class, some international schools have smaller classes. And/or facilities.

Anyway, I am curious to read too!

I am also wondering (but that's just my thought) whether ESF wouldn't have a higher percentage of expat children IF a lot of companies (still) wouldn't pay for children's schools. I mean, we pay out of pocket, it's quite a difference if you pay $60k a year or almost $150k at HKIS. Most people I know who have kids going to CDIS, HKIS, etc. have school paid for by their companies. I guess it can influence the decision if money doesn't play a role (that much). Even though we could afford other schools, we feel we rather spend it on secondary / university education instead of Primary. ESF applications for Year 1 were up 10% this year compared to last as well and Bradbury has a lot of Cat 1 (non Cantonese speakers) on the waiting list, so maybe something is changing in the current economic climate (just guessing though).
 
some reasons parents have for choosing alternative schools:

- don't want IB schools (PYP at the primary levels)
- want smaller class sizes
- location to where they live
- want a curriculum they feel better "fits" into their home country
- facilities

but as mum2sophie points out, the majority of parents who have children in other international schools are not paying for it themselves.

mum2sophie is bang on with applications being up 10 per cent at esf primary schools this year.

my son is at esf and we are pleased with it, especially with the quality of teachers.
 
This is the most dreadful reason (against ESF) I've been given:

"Honestly, there's nothing wrong with the teachers or curriculum, there's just not enough Caucasian kids around. Too many Chinese kids. I don't want my child to grow up in that environment."

However, this is the best (for ESF):

"If i had to choose all over again for my kids, I'd choose ESF... U should because at least unlike the XIS, it's professionally run since it's been revamped. At XIS, the money that the school receives clearly does not go into running the school to benefit the children. A school is not a round the corner fish and chips shop run by a small minded man."*

*This is NOT a respond from a parent at GSIS. This was about another international school on the NT/Kowloon side.
 

About this archive

This is an archive of over 20 years of GeoBaby and GeoSchools knowledge and discussions, kept online as a read-only reference.

Back
Top