PIPS or Greenfield Playgroup??

[carang]

there is a small local kindergarten in sai kung. i've written about it many times. Sai Kung Lok Yuk Kindergarten. They have many expat kids, mixed kids and local kids. the language of instruction is cantonese, but all of the kids catch on very quickly, especially when they are so young!

if you want your kid to go local, you need to start in kindergarten. there is no way a child could play "catch up" starting P1.

as for your family immersing in a a new language being dependent on the child.... i think it had a lot more to do with the ages of the children...a 4 year old will pick up language much faster than a 12 year old... at least that is usually how it works.

you are worried you haven't seen any endorsements for a school which opened 3 months ago? i would be very surprised if there were any! that isn't very much time...

 

[charade]

I am also interested in all the schools wishkiez mentioned so would love to get feedback. With Greenfield though, my understanding is that it is an International school so medium of instruction English with a Putonghua/Cantonese component thrown in. I visited the Hang Hau campus some time ago - is it bilingual? Can't remember...but I do remember the staff seemed friendly.

If you're truly serious about going the local route, I would do as Cara suggested and go with a Cantonese kindergarten. That's the only way the child would pick up enough Cantonese to be comfortable in a Cantonese-medium primary school... or possibly even a local English medium school where most of the kids in the schoolyard would speak Cantonese (and also I heard some of the prestigious English-medium local schools would like the kids to have some level of profiency in Chinese so they don't bring down the overall school grade since Chinese is a compulsory subject in competitive exams in the local system).

But for me, if I was going that route, I'd want to find a kindergarten that is expat-friendly, even if the medium of instruction is Chinese. So a school that is used to dealing with expat parents who may not be able to read the regular circulars and where there are a handful of expat kids so one's kid is not the only foreigner in the schoolyard. This is a bigger concern for me because we are Indian; a Caucasian kid might have an easier time. There seem to be a couple of such options in Sai Kung (the one Cara mentioned also Sunlight Internationa) but not in TKO as far as I know.

Going to an international school with local kids... not sure how that would prep a kid for local primary. Maybe if it was bilingual...

 

[carang]

the school i mentioned sends all info out in english or chinese (as does my son's local, chinese primary school).

 

[charade]

the school i mentioned sends all info out in english or chinese (as does my son's local, chinese primary school).

Yes, Cara but this doesn't seem to be the case in some of the kindergartens I checked out in the TKO area. I think the school you mentioned and Sunlight, which is also in Sai Kung, do this because they have at least a handful of expat kids. I tried to the bus ride to Sai Kung and it's too long...I would love to find such an option in TKO, but it's hard to know except through word of mouth because from the govt website there are so many schools - all with Chinese only websites - that if I had to visit each one, I'd have to take a month of work.

So, Cantonese-medium expat-friendly schools in TKO anyone?

 

[carang]

yes, i realise it might not be the case for all schools...

 

[Zergmei]

hi
sorry for the late reply.

I tried greenfield (longbeach) from may and decided to pull her out on the first day of school.
however, getting back to tutortime has been tough. she will only return to tutortime at the end of July.

the teachers aren't very enthusiastic about the children. so the teachers do their jobs (as though by the handbook) and don't really facilitate the children's learning. the children thus don't pay much attention and go about doing their own things. The teachers use youtube videos to teach songs and can't even sing along in tune.

the combination of english and putonghua all at the same time confuses the children and my daughter went from speaking 30% putonghua to completely zero. they don't seem to learn anything at all!

I went to their parent teacher meetings where they showed videos of what happens in class and I was very disappointed and felt glad that I made the decision to withdraw her fast.

Also, hygiene may be an issue as the toilets are not ensuit so the kids don't wash their hands often enough.
in the first month my daughter was there, she got hand foot mouth.
in the second month, she had tonsilitis.
in the third month, she had pneumonia.
I can't wait to get her out of school.

Greenfield has good ideas, ie homework to inculcate a good habit of sitting down to do work.

too bad about the execution.

Hi Zergmei

Am about to enrol my son at Greenfield (the new Hang Hau campus). Could you be specific about the negative comments you have heard about Greenfield please? My options are Sunshine House (Clear Water Bay), Boxhill (TKO) and Greenfield. We want to prep my son for wider options for Primary in case he doesn't get into any of the Inter and ESF. The most important factor would be htat he enjoys his time at school though, even if it means he has little choice at P1 level.

 

[charade]

Thanks for coming back with your feedback on Greenfield...One hopes the different branches have different management and hence Hang Hau might be better. Then again, your feedback does speak badly of the brand itself.

 

[Gracey]

I'm looking for playgroups for my 1-year-old daughter near Olympic.

Greenfield. They seemed very friendly. A receptionist addressed me in fluent English first (though I later switched to Cantonese). They let my daughter "have a little play" even though school was over. There were a few teachers lingering around, and they were very friendly to my daughter and asked many questions. The only downside is that it's English / Putonghua, and I want my daughter to learn Cantonese.

Learning Habitat. They were less friendly. The two women at reception basically just handed over an application form. When I asked questions, they told me to go to the website. When I asked to see the playroom, they refused and said there would be an open house in October! I mean, it was empty and I only wanted a few minutes to peek in. The only plus is that they teach in English / Cantonese, which is perfect for us.

BOC Kindergarden. This place is run by the HK Society of the Protection of Children, so I don't know if it is only for needy children. It was closed when I went. But I like the idea of my child going to a local Cantonese place.

Any experiences out there?

 

[OlympicMummy]

Hello, instead of PIPS and Greenfield, I decided to send my daughter to Tutor Time playgroup in Kowloon Tong and I think I made a good choice. Just more expensive with the taxi fare but so far, worth it.

I'm rethinking about pre-Nursery class (daily) as Greenfield and PIPS are closer to us. Will see if a place may be offered in either.
Posted via Mobile Device

 

[Zergmei]

good choice!